Tuberculosis vaccine development for cattle should be a priority says Rob Marris MP

Tuberculosis vaccine development for cattle should be a priority says Rob Marris MP

Like This Video 889 wildtalkadmin
Added by November 30, 2016

From his questions asked in parliament, Rob Marris MP has discovered that the development of a tuberculosis vaccine for cattle has been sacrificed in favour of a costly compensation scheme for farmers.

Since 1998 the government has paid out an £341 million in compensation to farmers for the slaughter of cattle infected with TB, but has spent only £35 million on research to develop a tuberculosis vaccination and associated diagnostics.

Rob Marris said: “Prevention is better than cure for both farmer and badger – yet these astonishing figures indicate a skewed set of priorities. Since 1998, government has spent on average £19 million per year in compensation and only £1.9 million on research. If the government keeps focussing on compensating farmers at the expense of developing a tuberculosis vaccine, we’ll all end up paying out for evermore.”

The development of a vaccination would help both farmers and badgers – animals which are currently facing the largest ever cull, with the government recently announcing a tripling of the areas where badgers can be culled. The loss of cattle can be heart-breaking for farmers, and is not a short-term problem. Nor can it be solved through compensation. According to the ‘Farm Crisis Network’, slaughter can have a longer term impact on the growth of a farm, and only one third of farmers said the compensation covered the loss.

Mr Marris commented: “It is right that there is a compensation scheme for farmers whose cattle are devastated by the spread of tuberculosis, but it is wrong that the government spends such a relatively small amount of funding into a viable tuberculosis vaccination. That discrepancy must not continue. There is a clear economic argument to implement a stronger policy of ‘prevention’ (vaccination) rather than the ‘cure’ (compensation) which is costing the taxpayers tens of millions a year.”

Dominic Dyer CEO of the Badger Trust & Policy Adviser Born Free Foundation said: “Trials in Ethiopia and Mexico have shown that a tuberculosis vaccine could be 58-68% effective in preventing the spread of bovine tuberculosis in cattle.

“For the past 5 years the government has stated it will trial a tuberculosis vaccine for cattle in the UK. In 2014 Defra commissioned a consortium including Triveritas UK, scientists from the Animal Health and Veterinary Laboratories Agency and Cambridge University to design field trials in the UK.

“Triveritas, which specialises in undertaking livestock field trials, was to design the trial for the tuberculosis vaccine together with a new diagnostic test for differentiating between infected and immunised cows

“Despite the importance of developing a tuberculosis vaccine for cattle, Defra announced in 2015 that it had called off the trial on cost grounds.

“This decision causing anger and concern in both the farming and wildlife conservation sectors. However the government has made no new commitment to move forward with a tuberculosis vaccine trial for cattle since the 2015 General Election.

“We are now calling on the Defra Secretary of State Andrea Leadson to urgently move forward with a tuberculosis vaccine for cattle in the UK, as this will provide a highly effective means of lowering the spread of bovine TB in cattle, without having to waste tens of millions of pounds of public money on a scientifically ineffective and cruel badger cull.”

Similar Videos

Campaigners protest against the Government’s plan to extend badger cull into Herefordshire.

1347 0

On Saturday the 21st November 2015 I joined hundreds of campaigners from all over England and Wales on the streets of Hereford to protest against the controversial badger cull and the Government’s proposals to extend it into Herefordshire in 2016.

Europe’s oldest forest is threatened by a beetle infestation. “Let nature take its course” says Forest Ecologist Lucinda Kirkpatrick

1338 1

Białowieża Forest in Poland represents the last European lowland natural forest and is a UNESCO World Heritage Site. In this article Lucinda Kirkpatrick, PhD Researcher in Forest Ecology at the University of Stirling, explains how its unique ecosystem and ecological processes

A vote for the Conservatives is a vote for the badger cull.

3110 0

In an attempt to secure the votes of the farming community, Environment Minister Liz Truss has pledged that badger culls will continue under a new Conservative led government after the May general election and that culling will form an integral